Eagles trade a 1, 2 and a 3 to move up 6 spots in this years draft
In very unsurprising news, the Eagles have decided to make yet another off-season splash and sent future picks to the Browns to move up to the second round in this year's draft. Obviously this is a polarizing decision by Philly management, and here are our #HotTakes on the subject:
Dom:
The Eagles are fresh off a pretty... *ahem* very mediocre season in which quarterback play was quite a rollercoaster ride. Former trade acquisition Sam Bradford left fans wondering what could have been after toasting the Giants in the final game under the tutelage of a Chip Kelly-less coaching staff. Management decides to sign this guy for 2 more years on a contract worth 24 mil, and then they go out and get their new head coach's project in Chase Daniels for a 12 million dollar contract. OK, the QB situation is pretty locked up in Philly, right? WRONG! I personally can't believe the audacity of Roseman and Co.... to trade up in a historically mediocre QB draft, where everyone only wants QBs because the likes of Manning, Brees and other top tier quarterbacks are on their last legs, and, frankly, other top QB picks in the past few years have been extremely overhyped. Yes the NFL is a passing league. Yes the quarterback is the guy touching the ball on every single goddamn play, but is drafting one 2nd overall really worth throwing away 3 potentially productive players for? Especially when you're only moving up 6 picks to do so, I honestly don't believe that trading up in a draft to get into the top 5 is worth it at all. I haven't even talked about the players yet an im in utter disagreement with this decision.
Carson Wentz and Jared Goff. Before the focus of the NFL talk turned to the draft, I doubt 80% of NFL fans could have told me that these guys were two 'top tier' quarterbacks and not a tight end and offensive tackle from the University of Nebraska. I'll give credit where it is due: these guys are two talented quarterbacks. Now are they talented enough to go 1 and 2 overall in a draft with absolute studs like Laremy Tunsil, Jalen Ramsey and Ezekiel Elliot? HECK NO. Wentz is a proven winner, but the dude played in North Dakota for chrissakes. You can pull the Romo/Big Ben card and say that the guy doesn't have to play big time football to be a good NFL QB, but I could pull that same card with the bagillion other small time quarterbacks that didn't even come close to making it in the league. I'd take the guy realistically at the 5 spot because he is very promising, it's just there are absolute generational talents in this draft that you can't pass up on.
Then there's Jared Goff. The small-handed Cali boy who absolutely lit up the Pac 12 last year, right? CAL WENT 8-5. As a player, the dude can spin the ball with anyone but honestly I question his arm strength and overall physique. Is he going to be able to take the inevitable beating that he will take year in and year out with this swiss cheese of an offensive line that the Eagles seem content with sending out each year? For some reason I see a Jeff Garcia with hair in his future, which probably isn't worth taking him as a top pick in this year's draft.
Long story short, do we need a franchise QB? I'm leaning towards Sam Bradford maybe isn't the answer. Was this the draft to find one? Probably not. Bad move by management, I''ll give it a C.
Matt:
Welcome back, Howie. You can like this or you can hate this, which seems to be the more popular opinion, but you don't really know what this is until three or four years from now. Either guy, Jared Goof(spelling error but it works better) or Carson Wentz, need some time to learn under NFL quarterbacks and coaches. I wonder if there is a team that has some experienced NFL quarterbacks and coaches, hmmmm. Enter Philadelphia. Dougie P(it'll catch on) and Frank Reich played quarterback in the league and John DeFilippo played a little in college but is the quarterbacks coach. Sam Bradford has been around for a little and Chase Daniel has been around for a while. So they aren't Tom Brady and Bill Belichik but they're something.
The Eagles aren't going to win the Super Bowl this year or the next with the 8th pick or with the 2nd pick. They have a solid defense to build on and a good base on offense but they're absolutely lacking a franchise quarterback. Bradford has yet to prove himself and is most likely not the solution but Carson Wentz, the likely player to fall to #2, might be with the right coaching and situation. Would he work out in Cleveland? My money is on no, and that is true for a lot of places, but Philadelphia is a situation that can help a young quarterback. He's a big dude with a coachable skill set who has won before. Yes, he did play FCS football but for the best FCS team there has ever been and an FCS team that beat FBS teams or gave them a run for their money. Joe "Elite" Flacco played at University of Deleware and won a Super Bowl, as did Kurt Warner who did not start ever at Northern Iowa.
Come 2020 and Wentz is bagging groceries in a 200 person North Dakota town, you can rip me, but until then there is no reason to hate or love this trade. Speculate all you want, I sure am, but there are no definites at this point in the trade. What is definite is that you need a franchise quarterback to win in this league and that is something Philadelphia has lacked since McNabb left so why not go for one when the price is low(er than normal)?
Long story short, do we need a franchise QB? I'm leaning towards Sam Bradford maybe isn't the answer. Was this the draft to find one? Probably not. Bad move by management, I''ll give it a C.
Matt:
Welcome back, Howie. You can like this or you can hate this, which seems to be the more popular opinion, but you don't really know what this is until three or four years from now. Either guy, Jared Goof(spelling error but it works better) or Carson Wentz, need some time to learn under NFL quarterbacks and coaches. I wonder if there is a team that has some experienced NFL quarterbacks and coaches, hmmmm. Enter Philadelphia. Dougie P(it'll catch on) and Frank Reich played quarterback in the league and John DeFilippo played a little in college but is the quarterbacks coach. Sam Bradford has been around for a little and Chase Daniel has been around for a while. So they aren't Tom Brady and Bill Belichik but they're something.
The Eagles aren't going to win the Super Bowl this year or the next with the 8th pick or with the 2nd pick. They have a solid defense to build on and a good base on offense but they're absolutely lacking a franchise quarterback. Bradford has yet to prove himself and is most likely not the solution but Carson Wentz, the likely player to fall to #2, might be with the right coaching and situation. Would he work out in Cleveland? My money is on no, and that is true for a lot of places, but Philadelphia is a situation that can help a young quarterback. He's a big dude with a coachable skill set who has won before. Yes, he did play FCS football but for the best FCS team there has ever been and an FCS team that beat FBS teams or gave them a run for their money. Joe "Elite" Flacco played at University of Deleware and won a Super Bowl, as did Kurt Warner who did not start ever at Northern Iowa.
Come 2020 and Wentz is bagging groceries in a 200 person North Dakota town, you can rip me, but until then there is no reason to hate or love this trade. Speculate all you want, I sure am, but there are no definites at this point in the trade. What is definite is that you need a franchise quarterback to win in this league and that is something Philadelphia has lacked since McNabb left so why not go for one when the price is low(er than normal)?